Sunday, May 09, 2010

A.L. FAAB Supplemental: Michael Saunders

Depending on whom you listen to, Michael Saunders is either a potential future superstar who simply needs to work on his plate discipline or a somewhat overhyped prospect who could have a solid career but not a great one. If you're in a deep A.L.-only league, you've probably heard about Saunders for at least a couple of years now, but he's "only" 23 years old and still has a little more time to establish himself as a prospect.

Those who view players from a scouting standpoint love Saunders because he's athletic, toolsy and is described as having a lot of strength and agility. "Tools" is the operative word here. The drawback is that Saunders thus far has been unable to translate his raw ability into statistical prowess. After a 29 steal performance between A/AA in 2007, Saunders has dropped off each of the last two seasons. His whiff totals are high while his walk totals leave something to be desired. And - most importantly - Saunders has been somewhat erratic in the power department.

The Mariners called up Saunders due mostly to need, not performance. Saunders had a 293/213/506 slash line in 80 AB at Tacoma and was really floundering. If there's a silver lining here, it's that Saunders had rallied in his last five games prior to his call-up with a 583/500/1083 slash in 18 AB. A terribly small sample size, I know, but Saunders backers need something to hang their hats on here.

Saunders' biggest point in his favor right now is the Mariners desperate need. His main competition in the OF now is Ryan Langerhans. I think Saunders is up to play, and while he probably won't be great, he is talented enough that he's worth the risk if you're looking for lightning in a bottle. I'd bid $11 if you're desperate, but a more realistic bid is $4. That might not get him, but it's hard to recommend Saunders right at this moment.

No comments: